George, forgiving and forgetting is something that isn't very easily done. Definitely not when trust has been broken several times.
I think if you do end up being unbanned at all, we are first going to need some time.
Maybe more discussion, maybe some more time to see if you have actually matured.
Most of the people are against you being unbanned, and I personally am against you being unbanned right now as well. I feel more nuetral about this than anything. I know others are tired of this, and just agree that this case should be closed completely. As I have said before, I disagree with this. I think it shouldn't completely close forever because of the reasons I've already said. I mean on one hand what you did was very wrong; you abused the trust of the community, and you only have yourself to blame for it, but on the other, this is a game we are talking about, and people will end up making stupid mistakes when they're young. It doesn't really mean they should be banned forever for it, but what I do understand is an unban should only be given if everyone is fine with it, and of course with certain conditions.
I did have a lot more to write on this, but decided to hold it back, because it would probably be taken the wrong way. Mainly since it was a lot of ranting. =P
I can post it if people feel they have the time, and if they feel it's worth reading, but for now I'll just leave it out.
The long story short version of what i was going to say is to come back to this in a couple of months, and then see how you feel. Don't completely forsake him for this, since NO previous member of the community, no matter how long or short a time period they have been here for, should be banned for good if there's the chance of redeeming themselves.
Once again, leave it a couple of months, and come back to it later. He can still stay banned if you feel the same then. Any other opinions are welcomed in the meantime, of course.
I think if you do end up being unbanned at all, we are first going to need some time.
Maybe more discussion, maybe some more time to see if you have actually matured.
Most of the people are against you being unbanned, and I personally am against you being unbanned right now as well. I feel more nuetral about this than anything. I know others are tired of this, and just agree that this case should be closed completely. As I have said before, I disagree with this. I think it shouldn't completely close forever because of the reasons I've already said. I mean on one hand what you did was very wrong; you abused the trust of the community, and you only have yourself to blame for it, but on the other, this is a game we are talking about, and people will end up making stupid mistakes when they're young. It doesn't really mean they should be banned forever for it, but what I do understand is an unban should only be given if everyone is fine with it, and of course with certain conditions.
I did have a lot more to write on this, but decided to hold it back, because it would probably be taken the wrong way. Mainly since it was a lot of ranting. =P
I can post it if people feel they have the time, and if they feel it's worth reading, but for now I'll just leave it out.
The long story short version of what i was going to say is to come back to this in a couple of months, and then see how you feel. Don't completely forsake him for this, since NO previous member of the community, no matter how long or short a time period they have been here for, should be banned for good if there's the chance of redeeming themselves.
Once again, leave it a couple of months, and come back to it later. He can still stay banned if you feel the same then. Any other opinions are welcomed in the meantime, of course.