Last night, after consideration, me and LordofPain decided, due to shoe's exceptional performance on the server, that he should be promoted from guest, straight to H4. The reasons are the following; he has been on the server the required length of time but requested not to be promoted, his builds truly are exceptional, and despite some people thinking he stays quietly too much and just sticks to his own builds, i have noticed him offering help to others.
I know some players might be unhappy about my and lord's decision, so I set up this thread for people to discuss, so we can come to an overall decision. It may be that our actions to promote were a little hasty, but I do still stick by my opinion that he has earnt it.
For now, I would like to request that shoe remains as H4, until it is decided otherwise, either by a group decision on the whole by OPs and other players, or by Clownfish himself.
I understand why the rules on promotions are in place, probably more than some other people, but in this case I personally believed that shoe deserved to be an exception.
As I say, if anybody disagrees, feel free to raise concerns, and we can discuss any actions to be taken if the majority feels that lord and I acted out of turn.
I know some players might be unhappy about my and lord's decision, so I set up this thread for people to discuss, so we can come to an overall decision. It may be that our actions to promote were a little hasty, but I do still stick by my opinion that he has earnt it.
For now, I would like to request that shoe remains as H4, until it is decided otherwise, either by a group decision on the whole by OPs and other players, or by Clownfish himself.
I understand why the rules on promotions are in place, probably more than some other people, but in this case I personally believed that shoe deserved to be an exception.
As I say, if anybody disagrees, feel free to raise concerns, and we can discuss any actions to be taken if the majority feels that lord and I acted out of turn.